Baixar Notícia
WhatsApp
Email

TST holds Post Offices responsible for precarious working conditions of outsourced

Fonte: jurinews.com.br | Data: 04/11/2026 16:59:16

🔗 Ler matéria original

panel pushed the state’s obligation on labor funds, keeping only compensation for moral damages.

The 1st panel of the TST (Higher Labor Court) maintained the subsidiary responsibility of the Post Offices for payment of compensation for moral damages to a vigilante outsourced. The worker was subjected to precarious conditions in a deactivated building of the public company, where there was no electricity, drinking water or toilets in conditions of use. The panel decided to remove the state’s obligation to answer for the labor funds, but preserved the condemnation of compensation for the lack of dignified conditions in the company’s dependencies.

In the lawsuit, the vigilante pleaded for the receipt of labor funds and compensation for moral damages. In analyzing the case, the TRT of the 2nd region (Regional Labor Court of the 2nd Region) recognized the subsidiary responsibility of the public company, a mode in which the taker of the services responds for payment if the direct employer does not comply with the obligation. The regional court considered that the Post Offices did not demonstrate that they had adequately monitored the performance of labor obligations by the provider company.

The regional decision also recorded that there was no proof of payment of the rescissional funds and that the employee did not fully enjoy the interval of one hour for rest and food. Os Correios resorted to the TST, stating that they could not be held responsible for the debts of the contractor and that it would be up to the worker to prove any failure in the supervision. Initially, the 1st panel maintained the conviction, but again examined the controversy after the trial of Theme 1.118 by the STF (Supreme Federal Court), which attributed to the author the burden of proving the negligence of the Public Administration in the supervision of the labor obligations of the contracted company.

The rapporteur of the case, Minister Hugo Carlos Scheuermann, explained that the Supreme removed the possibility of holding the Public Administration responsible for labor debts of outsourced companies on sole grounds of inversion of the burden of proof. According to the thesis established, it is up to the author to demonstrate the effective existence of negligent behavior of the government or the causal link between the alleged damage and the conduct of the contracting entity. In the case under consideration, the rapporteur noted that the conviction of the Post Office for labor funds had been based on the lack of proof of supervision, which is why he concluded that this responsibility should be removed to suit the judgment to the orientation of the STF.

Scheuermann distinguished, however, the labor credits typical of compensation for moral damages, arguing that the compensation for the absence of decent working conditions is based on the rules of civil liability. The minister’s vote reproduced excerpt from the thesis of the STF according to which it is up to the Public Administration to ensure conditions of safety, hygiene and health when the work is carried out in their premises or in a place previously agreed in contract. “It is the responsibility of the Public Administration to ensure the conditions of safety, hygiene and health of workers, when the work is carried out in their premises or place previously agreed in contract, in accordance with article 5a, § 3o, of law 6.019/74”, said the magistrate.

In this context, the rapporteur concluded that the moral damage came from the conditions of the post located in the property of the Post Office, especially from the lack of electricity, drinking water and toilets in conditions of use. Accompanying the understanding, the panel gave partial provision to the use of the Post Office to remove the subsidiary responsibility for labor funds, keeping it for compensation for moral damages.

Case: RR-1382-74.2012.5.02.0083