TST decides that industrious does not lose free justice by having car and motorcycle
Fonte: jurinews.com.br | Data: 05/11/2026 11:01:25
panel understood that possession of modest goods and income higher than 40% of the RGPS ceiling do not automatically exclude the condition of undersufficiency.
The Third panel of the Superior Labor Court (TST) restored the benefit of free justice to a worker in the execution phase of the Labour judgment. The benefit, granted at the initial stage of the proceedings, had been revoked by the Regional Labor Court of the 12th Region (TRT-12), which considered that the worker would be able to bear the procedural costs. For the panel, however, the fact that it receives more than 40% of the social security ceiling and has a small equity does not necessarily imply financial availability.
The action was moved by a leak from the Tupy S.A., Joinville (SC), who, from the beginning of the action, claimed that he was unable to afford the costs and fees without harming his livelihood and that of his family. The first-degree judgment granted free justice and received part of the applications, and the TRT, when judging appeal, considered that the company was entitled to the sucumbent fees (due by the losing party to the winning party) in respect of parcels that were not recognised.
In the implementation phase, however, the TRT revoked free justice on the grounds that its financial capacity was demonstrated. The decision took into account that he received a salary greater than 40% of the ceiling of the General Social Security Regime (RGPS) and owned a car and a motorcycle. According to the TRT, he could sell the motorcycle to pay off the debt. The worker then resorted to TST.
In judging the case, the ministers of the 3rd panel were unanimous in maintaining the vote of the rapporteur, Minister Mauricio Godinho Delgado. “The existence of modest equity does not necessarily imply immediate financial availability or capacity to bear the costs of the process,” he said.
Although the TRT had registered that the worker had a monthly salary of R$ 4,265, the minister observed that, according to a consolidated understanding of the TST (Tema 21), the receipt of salary money with values above 40% of the RGPS ceiling does not in itself rule out the condition of lack of resources.
According to the rapporteur, the determining factor to ward off the benefit of free justice is not the income or quantity of goods, but its ability to “carry out procedural expenses without prejudice to one’s own livelihood or family.” Income above 40% of the RGPS ceiling, just as it does not guarantee the benefit of free justice automatically, does not automatically exclude it. A specific and individualised analysis of each case is required.
Process: Ag-RR-0000053-04.2021.5.12.0028
With information from TST.