Baixar Notícia
WhatsApp
Email

Outsourced company cannot appeal decision that excludes subsidiary state liability

Fonte: jurinews.com.br | Data: 06/11/2026 11:16:02

🔗 Ler matéria original

Decisão da Quarta panel of the TST maintains Nurses – Serviços de Saúde da Amazônia Ltda. as the sole responsible for the payment of labor funds.

The Fourth panel of the Superior Labor Court (TST) rejected appeal in which Nurses – Serviços de Saúde da Amazônia Ltda. intended to restore the subsidiary responsibility of the State of Amazonas for labor money due to a nursing technique. According to panel, the company remains obliged to pay the amounts due to the employee, regardless of the responsibility of the public body.

In subsidiary liability, the taker of services responds to the payment of labor debts if the service provider does not settle the amounts due.

In the labor complaint, the technique, contracted by Nurses to provide services to the state, obtained the recognition of various labor funds. The first-degree judgment declared the subsidiary liability of Amazonas if Nurse did not pay the values recognised in judgment. Both the company and the State of Amazonas appealed to the Regional Labor Court of the 11th Region (TRT-11). The company questioned the conviction for moral damages, and the state asked to remove subsidiary liability, with the argument that it had never been an employer of the technique.

The TRT-11 maintained the judgment, as it understood that the public entity had an obligation to supervise compliance with the contract and failed. In the TST, Minister Alexandre Ramos, in a monocratic decision, dismissed subsidiary liability and dismissed the state’s claim for liability for the payment of labor parcels recognized in previous instances. Nurses appealed to this decision through aggravation, arguing that the TRT had recognized flaws in the supervision of the contract.

For the rapporteur, however, the interest in appeal depends on the possibility that the change in the decision will create a more favourable legal situation for the party presenting the appeal. In this case, the exclusion of the subsidiary liability of Amazonas does not alter the conviction imposed on Nurses, which remains the principal debtor of the amounts due to the employee.

Also according to the minister, the decision follows the understanding of the TST that the service provider has no recursal interest to question the inclusion or exclusion of the subsidiary responsibility of the taker when there is no obligation of the presence of the two in the process.

Case: Ag-RR-1149-09.2019.5.11.0010

With TST information.