TST decides to mass-dispense 212 Casa da Moeda employees sets up etharism
Fonte: jurinews.com.br | Data: 12/11/2026 14:26:53
panel determined the reintegration of workers and maintained condemnation for collective moral damage fixed at R $ 10 million
Subsection I Specialized in Dissídios Individuais (SDI-1) of the Superior Labor Court (TST) decided that the mass dispensation of 212 Casa da Moeda do Brasil employees, selected for being retired or entitled to retirement, was discriminatory. By the majority, the panel considered the measure invalid and determined the reintegration of the dismissed workers.
The National Workers Union at Indústria Moedeira questioned layoffs in public civil action. The entity reported that, in April 2018, Casa da Moeda informed the dispensations under the justification of an “economic-financial situation that the company goes through due to successive revenue losses”. The selection criterion was age, reaching those who were already retired or in a position to retire.
The union requested the cancellation of the shutdowns, the reintegration, the payment of salaries of the period of removal, the maintenance of the health plan and the conviction of the company for collective moral damage.
In its defense, the Casa da Moeda maintained that the shutdowns followed objective criteria, based on the possibility of employees having another source of income, such as retirement or the immediate right to benefit, in addition to the supplementary pension offered by the state. The company argued that the measure was motivated by a loss of operating revenue estimated at R$ 1.4 billion resulting from closed contracts.
The Regional Labor Court of the 1st Region (TRT-1) had annulled the dispensations and determined the reintegration with full reimbursement of the values of the period of removal, in addition to fixing compensation of R $ 10 million for collective moral damage.
According to TRT-1, evidence and the opinion of the Work Public Prosecutor’s Office (MPT) confirmed age discrimination, since the Casa da Moeda itself admitted the use of the pension condition or eligibility for retirement as a criterion.
Later, the TST Fifth panel removed the discriminatory character, understanding that the dismissals were part of a financial restructuring process, which led the union to resort to SDI-1.
AGE DISCRIMINATION
According to the rapporteur, Minister Augusto César, the use of the condition of retired or eligibility for retirement as a criterion for dismissal is directly linked to age and characterizes age discrimination.
The magistrate was based on the Protocol for Acting and Judgment with Perspectiva Antidiscriminatória, Intersectional and Inclusive of the TST, which guides the fight against discriminatory practices. The document defines etharism as “forms of prejudice, discrimination and oppression because of age, in which old age is seen as something undesirable or social burden”.
Augusto César stressed that etharism at work can occur by practices such as age restriction in vacancies, pressure to adhere to layoff programs, dismissal of older employees and violation of pre-retirement stability, conducts prohibited by Estatuto da Pessoa Idosa.
The minister stated that the TST consolidated the understanding that the exemption based on age or near retirement is discriminatory. According to the rapporteur, layoffs occurred in “indifferent to the case law of the TST and the Supreme Court” on the need for dialogue and collective negotiation. Minister Alexandre Ramos was defeated, arguing that the criterion of dispensation was the differentiated social security situation, not age.
CEEE SHOULD ALSO REINTEGRATE
In recent decisions, the Second panel of the TST also condemned the State Generation Company and Transmissão de Energia Elétrica (CEEE – GT) of the Rio Grande do Sul, to reintegrate two electricians discharged in 2016. The company claimed the need for structural adaptation to the guidelines of the National Electric Energy Agency (ANEEL) and adjustment of the payroll. However, Minister Delaíde Miranda Arantes, rapporteur of the appeal, understood that the retirement criterion reaches the most advanced age group disproportionately, configuring indirect discrimination prohibited by Law 9.029/1995 and the Federal Constitution.
Processes: Emb-ED-RRAg-00339-71.2018.5.01.0037, RRAg-20217-71.2017.5.04.0571 and RRAg-2067-83.2017.5.04.0013